Search publications
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://researchpubs.cancercouncil.com.au//cancercounciljspui/handle/1/2118
Title: The predicted impact and cost‐effectiveness of systematic testing of people with incident colorectal cancer for Lynch syndrome
Authors: Kang Y;Killen J;Caruana M;Simms K;Taylor N;Frayling I;Snowsill T;Huxley N;Coupe V;Hughes S;Freeman V;Boussioutas A;Trainer A;Ward R;Mitchell G;Macrae F;Canfell K
Categories: Early Detection, Diagnosis, and Prognosis - Resources and Infrastructure
Year: 2020
Journal Title: Medical Journal of Australia
Volume: 212
Issue: 2
Abstract: Objectives To evaluate the health impact and cost‐effectiveness of systematic testing for Lynch syndrome (LS) in people with incident colorectal cancer (CRC) in Australia. Design, setting, participants We investigated the impact of LS testing strategies in a micro‐simulation model (Policy1–Lynch), explicitly modelling the cost of testing all patients diagnosed with incident CRC during 2017, with detailed modelling of outcomes for patients identified as LS carriers (probands) and their at‐risk relatives throughout their lifetimes. For people with confirmed LS, we modelled ongoing colonoscopic surveillance. Main outcome measures Cost‐effectiveness of six universal tumour testing strategies (testing for DNA mismatch repair deficiencies) and of universal germline gene panel testing of patients with incident CRC; impact on cost‐effectiveness of restricting testing by age at CRC diagnosis (all ages, under 50/60/70 years) and of colonoscopic surveillance interval (one, two years). Results The cost‐effectiveness ratio of universal tumour testing strategies (annual colonoscopic surveillance, no testing age limit) compared with no testing ranged from $28 915 to $31 904/life‐year saved (LYS) (indicative willingness‐to‐pay threshold: $30 000–$50 000/LYS). These strategies could avert 184–189 CRC deaths with an additional 30 597–31 084 colonoscopies over the lifetimes of 1000 patients with incident CRC with LS and 1420 confirmed LS carrier relatives (164–166 additional colonoscopies/death averted). The most cost‐effective strategy was immunohistochemistry and BRAF V600E testing (incremental cost‐effectiveness ratio [ICER], $28 915/LYS). Universal germline gene panel testing was not cost‐effective compared with universal tumour testing strategies (ICER, $2.4 million/LYS). Immunohistochemistry and BRAF V600E testing was cost‐effective at all age limits when paired with 2‐yearly colonoscopic surveillance (ICER, $11 525–$32 153/LYS), and required 4778–15 860 additional colonoscopies to avert 46–181 CRC deaths (88–103 additional colonoscopies/death averted). Conclusions Universal tumour testing strategies for guiding germline genetic testing of people with incident CRC for LS in Australia are likely to be cost‐effective compared with no testing. Universal germline gene panel testing would not currently be cost‐effective.
Division: Cancer Research Division
Funding Body: National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC; GNT1080246) and the Cancer Council NSW (STREP: SRP 13‐02).
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.50356
URI: http://researchpubs.cancercouncil.com.au//cancercounciljspui/handle/1/2118
Appears in Collections:Research Articles

Files in This Item:
There are no files associated with this item.


Items in ResearchPubs are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.