Search publications
Title: Process evaluation of a behaviour change approach to improving clinical practice for detecting hereditary cancer
Authors: Long JC; Winata T; Debono D; Phan-Thien K-C; Zhu C; Taylor N
Categories: Cancer Type - Bowel Colorectal Cancer
Year: Mar-2019
Journal Title: BMC Health Services Research
Volume: 19
Issue: 180
Abstract: Background This retrospective process evaluation reports on the application of a 1-year implementation program to increase identification and management of patients at high risk of a hereditary cancer syndrome. The project used the Theoretical Domains Framework Implementation (TDFI) approach, a promising implementation methodology, used successfully in the United Kingdom to address patient safety issues. This Australian project run at two large public hospitals aimed to increase referrals of patients flagged as being at risk of Lynch syndrome on the basis of a screening test to genetic services. At the end of the project, the pathologists’ processes had changed, but the referral rate remained inconsistent and low. Methods Semi-structured interviews explored participants’ perceptions of the TDFI approach and Health services researchers wrote structured reflections. Interview transcripts and reflections were coded initially against implementation outcomes for the various TDFI approach activities: acceptability, appropriateness, feasibility, value for time cost, and adoption. On a second pass, themes were coded around challenges to the approach. Results Interviews were held with nine key project participants including pathologists, oncologists, surgeons, genetic counsellors and an administrative officer. Two health services researchers wrote structured reflections. The first of two major themes was ‘Theory-related challenges’, with subthemes of accessibility of theory underpinning the TDFI, commitment to that theory-based approach, and the problem of complexity. The second theme was ‘Practical challenges’ with subthemes of stakeholder management, navigating the system, and perceptions of the problem. Health services researchers reflected on the benefits of bridging professional divides and facilitating collective learning and problem solving, but noted frustrations around clinicians’ time constraints that led to sparse interactions with the team, and lack of authority to effect change themselves. Conclusions Mixed success of adoption as an outcome was attributed to the complexity and highly nuanced nature of the setting. This made identifying the target behaviour, a key step in the TDFI approach, challenging. Introduced changes in the screening process led to new, unexpected issues yet to be addressed. Strategies to address challenges are presented, including using an internal facilitator with a focus on applying a theory-based implementation approach.
Division: Cancer Research Division
Funding Body: This evaluation project was partially funded by the 2016 Premier’s Award for Excellence in Translational Cancer Research through the Cancer Institute New South Wales, Australia. The funding body had no influence on the design, data collection or analysis, or the write up for publication. NT was supported by a CINSW Career Development Fellowship.
DOI: 10.1186/s12913-019-3985-5
URI: http://researchpubs.cancercouncil.com.au/cancercounciljspui/handle/1/2078
Appears in Collections:Research Articles

Files in This Item:
There are no files associated with this item.


Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.